Vegan Chocolate Covered P...

$16

Chocolate Peanut Butter C...

$29

Dark Chocolate Bark

$11

360 Cashmere Velma Dark C...

$388

Alicja Confections - Popp...

$10

Pralus Equateur 75% Dark ...

$15

Cookies and Peanut Butter...

$60

Pralus Le 100% Dark Choco...

$14

Cleansing Bars

$14

Peanut Butter Brownie Cer...

$17

Seahorse Trinidad 70% Dar...

$16

Monster Cookie Protein Pe...

$20

K Cup Second Cup Paradiso...

$17

Bourbon Pecan Pie Milk Ch...

$12

Hogarth Chocolate Dark Ch...

$14

Soma Old School Dark Choc...

$18

The Chocolatier Salted Pe...

$10

Torani, Peanut Butter Syr...

$21

Peanut Butter Corduroy Ro...

$59

Chocolate Peanut Butter P...

$42

Dark Chocolate Raisin Tru...

$24

Apple Granola Crunch Prot...

$20

Dark Chocolate Favorites ...

$49

3-Pack Chocolate Almond B...

$41

Cookie Butter Chocolate B...

$10

K Cup Coffee Timothy's Ge...

$17

Cookie Dough Milk Chocola...

$12

Peanut Butter

$49

Dark Chocolate Truffles V...

$26

Milk Chocolate Cookie Bar...

$10

Peanut Butter and Cinnamo...

$19

Peanut Butter Cups

$33

Peanut Butter Milk Chocol...

$10

Dark Chocolate Organic Ha...

$11

Mint Chocolate Chip Choco...

$12

Honeymoon Chocolate Semel...

$14

Dark Chocolate Covered Nu...

$65

Mom Peanut Butter Ribbed ...

$60

Ritual Madagascar 75% Dar...

$12

Dark Chocolate Bonbons

$30

Aruntam Tanzania 72% Dark...

$14

12 oz Kids Cup (Cotton Ca...

$55

AERIN Shagreen Pencil Cup...

$195

Dark Peanut Butter Chocol...

$14

Mini Peanut Butter Ribbed...

$48

Peanut Butter Chocolate C...

$19

Peppermint Ribbon Candy, ...

$15

Reyna Peanut Butter Soft ...

$151

Venchi 75% Dark Chocolate

$10

Coconut Cream Pie Milk Ch...

$12

Peanut Butter Seventies L...

$129

K Cup Cake Boss Chocolate...

$17

Peanut Butter Pearls

$16

Candy Cane Hot Chocolate ...

$18

Cookies & Cream Dark Whit...

$17

Peppermint Candy Canes Fi...

$14

Nut Butter Bars - 12 pack

$30

Dark Chocolate Coconut Tr...

$29

CANDY SCROLL RED CUP OF C...

$14

Sugarfina Box, Peanut But...

$10

Army of Dark Chocolate | ...

$16

Peanut Butter & Jelly Bon...

$17

Truffles - Peanut Butter ...

$16

K Cup Hurricane Butter To...

$17

SPRWMN Ankle Leggings Dar...

$753

Cleansing Bars

$12

Christmas Tree, peanut bu...

$16

Mint Chocolate Chunk Prot...

$33

Peanut butter filled mola...

$15

Milk & Dark Chocolate Box

$16

WAFFLE JOGGER | DARK CHOC...

$68

Nightcap Whisky Dark Choc...

$11

Chocolate Brownie Protein...

$33

Peanut Butter Pucks

$26

Raspberry Candy Canes Fil...

$14

Old World Christmas Peanu...

$12

Moku Chocolate Hazelnut D...

$11

Chocolate Peanut Butter T...

$29

Lake Champlain Chocolate ...

$15

Ritual Ecuador 85% Dark C...

$12

Peanut Butter Chocolate C...

$60

PB & J Sandwich Milk Choc...

$12

Cherry Candy Canes Filled...

$14

Valentine Dark Chocolate ...

$13

Pralus Ghana 75% Dark Cho...

$14

Peanut Butter Pretzel Bat...

$12

Mini Peanut Butter Cup - ...

$30

Puchero Guatemala 55% Dar...

$14

Peanut Butter Cup Dark Ch...

$12

8 pc Peanut Butter Smoot...

$14

SDG TEST - Peanut Butter ...

$39

Chocolate Fudge Brownie P...

$30

Askinosie Davao 77% Dark ...

$12

Champagne Dark Chocolate ...

$14

90’s Men's Orange Reese's...

$40

Peanut Butter Sea Salt Go...

$35

Peanut Butter & Jelly Lar...

$12

Peanut Butter Chocolate C...

$28

K Cup Cake Boss Chocolate...

$17

Pink Elephants Dark Choco...

$17